LT(jg) Francis Toner, USN

LT(jg) Toner, USN is a 2006 graduate of the US Merchant Marine Academy. He entered active duty service with the US Navy. He volunteered to serve in Afghanistan. He was killed in action on March 27, 2009 while challenging an attacker.

The following article appeared in the Fall 2011 edition of the US Merchant Marine Academy Alumni magazine, Kings Pointer:

Admiral Mullen Awards Silver Star to LT (jg) Francis L. Toner, USN’06

The nation’s top military officer presented, on September 23, 2011, a posthumous Silver Star to the widow of a heroic Navy officer who was killed in Afghanistan.

Navy Admiral Mike Mullen, Chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff, addressed the audience during the presentation ceremony of the Silver Star to Brooke Toner, wife of LT (jg) Francis L. Toner IV at the US Navy Memorial in Washington, DC, Sept. 23, 2011.

During a ceremony at the Navy Memorial here, Chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff Navy Admiral Mike Mullen told the hundreds of people in attendance that LT (jg) Francis L. Toner IV, USN ’06 faced death “tragically and heroically.”

Toner, 26, was deployed to Afghanistan with an embedded training team as garrison engineer mentor for the Afghan National Army’s 209th Corps at Forward Operating Base Shaheen, near Mazar-e-Sharif in northern Afghanistan.

He and three other officers were exercising, running around the camp’s perimeter on March 27, 2009, when an enemy fighter who had infiltrated the Afghan army attacked with a firearm. As Toner’s Silver Star citation recounts, “In seconds, officers were shot and lying wounded on the ground. The gunman proceeded to shoot one of the wounded officers. . . . Toner, unarmed, verbally challenged the insurgent and continued to advance until he was fatally wounded.” “I’ve been to enough [award presentations] and I’ve seen enough citations to know that he was basically walking straight into the enemy’s fire,” the chairman said of Toner’s actions. “We shouldn’t – and we won’t – ever, ever forget that service, that sacrifice,” the admiral added. “Because that is what makes us strong, as a military and as a nation.”

The chairman said today’s ceremony, attended largely by sailors in uniform, was particularly poignant for the Navy because Toner deployed as an individual augmentee, attached to an Army unit. “I started that [program] when I was [chief of naval operations],” the admiral said. Mullen said his experience in Vietnam and knowledge of ground operations made the decision to deploy individual sailors very simple.

“I knew the ground forces would bear the brunt, and every sailor I could get into the fight was going to relieve a soldier,” he said. The Navy and Air Force have had thousands of their members “in the sand” of Iraq and Afghanistan, Mullen said. “There are 12,000 there today, and that continues,” he said.

Rear Admiral Philip H. Greene, Jr., USMS ’78, Superintendent, US Merchant Marine Academy and several Cadet – Midshipman of the US Merchant Marine Academy, from which Toner graduated in 2006, were among those attending the ceremony.

“Welcome,” the chairman said to the midshipmen. “You’re our future, and this all happens faster than any of us know. And we appreciate that you would raise your hand and serve your country at this extraordinary time.”

Mullen said part of the speech he delivered at the Merchant Marine Academy two graduations ago focused on “that thread of Frankie Toner, who had graduated from there, who so many looked to for inspiration.”

Brooke Toner, who accepted her husband’s Silver Star, spoke during the ceremony and thanked everyone who attended.

“From the moment I got that knock on the door – which was the worst day of my life – I’ve been supported by my casualty assistance officer, by Admiral Mullen, by [Navy Rear Adm. Christopher J. Mossey, commander of Naval Facilities Engineering Command], by all of our friends who have wrapped their arms around our family to support us all,” she said.

Toner was born Sept. 26, 1982, in Panorama City, CA. He graduated from Westlake High School in 2001 and his family relocated to Narragansett, RI in 2002.

In the summer of 2002, Toner entered the US Merchant Marine Academy in Kings Point, NY where he earned a Bachelor of Science degree in marine engineering and shipyard management.

In May 2006, Toner was commissioned an ensign in the US Navy. He graduated from Navy Civil Engineer Corps Officer School in Port Hueneme, CA, September 2006, and was assigned to Pearl Harbor, HI.

He reported to Camp Mike Spann in Afghanistan in October 2008 for a one-year individual augmentee assignment.

Toner is survived by his wife, Brooke Toner; mother, Rebecca Toner; father, Francis Toner III; stepmother, Sharon; sister, Amanda; and brothers, John and Michael.

Toner was previously posthumously awarded the Purple Heart and Bronze Star with valor. The Silver Star is the third highest combat military decoration. – Kings Pointer – Fall 2011

View video of the Presentation on YouTube here: ‘Adm. Mike Mullen Presents Silver Star Awarded to Lt. j.g. Francis L. Toner IV

(Photo found on his wife’s blog dedicated to her husband)

Posted by FFry in Navy

You can leave a response, or trackback from your own site.

  • AndyFMF

    I guess I am a little confused. A Purple Heart and Silver Star were awarded in 2011 because, according to the citation, the gunman was an “insurgent”, yet according to articles published in 2009 there was a different story.

    “’The simple fact is that they were murdered in cold blood. The guy who shot them wasn’t some random bad guy who snuck on base wearing a stolen uniform; he was an army soldier who had been vetted through the [Afghan National Army] recruiting process and trained to their basic standards,’ Lucrezio said in an e-mail to Navy Times after the shooting.”

    And in another article “The military refuted initial reports that the sailors were killed by an insurgent wearing an Afghan army uniform. ‘He was not killed by an insurgent as the initial press release has stated. He was killed by an Afghanistan army personnel,’ said Denise Emsley, spokeswoman for Naval Facilities Engineering Command Hawaii.”

    Given the media’s penchant for fact-checking high-level awards, I’m certain that I will not be the only one seeking clarification and drawing parallels between this citation and other Silver Star citations (HM3 Rubio and HM3 Chiarini).

  • Jessy James

    As shown by our own Fort Hood massacre… just because you lie about who you are and make it into whatever training program you choose does not mean you are not an insurgent. Maybe he joined the Afghan Army to get closer to US soldiers so he could carry out his orders to kill infidels. Frankie is a hero. He was unarmed and charged someone firing on his comrades. It’s akin to jumping on a grenade to save your buddies.

  • Edward Cavanagh

    Ltjg Frankie Toner was a true hero!