A fellow Academy midÂ posted thisÂ piece for Thomas Ricksâ€™ blog questioning whether or not operations in Libya were constitutional. The masterpiece can be accessed here:
Yes, the Constitution gives Congress the power to declare war. No, President Obama did not ask Congress to drop bombs in Libya. I agree that the law is ambiguous on who can deploy military force in this situation, but that question should be left for constitutional law professors and politicians to debate (not officer candidates).
I quote, â€śIt is [servicemen and womenâ€™s] professional obligation and ethical duty to disobey their orders until constitutional and legal requirements are either changed or met.â€ť So because ENS X and the Commander-in-Chief differ on whether or not air strikes constitute war, ENS X should â€śdisobeyâ€ť POTUS. We wouldnâ€™t have a Constitution to begin with if we ran our military this way.